Make Payments Online

Schultheis Insurance gladly accepts clients’ payments at any of our convenient locations, by phone, or online. In addition, many insurance carriers offer convenient phone or online premium payment options. Click on the links below to make direct payments.

Auto Owners Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-288-8740 ($7.00 fee applies)
Pay online 
Personal insurance – pay with credit card
Business insurance – pay with checking account

Cincinnati Insurance Companies

Pay by phone: 1-800-364-3400

Pay online with credit card or electronic fund transfer

Foremost Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-527-3905
Pay online with credit card or bank account

Hastings Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-442-8277 Ext. 1572
Pay online with credit card or bank account

Illinois Casualty Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-445-3726 (fees apply)
Pay online with credit card (fees apply)

Indiana Farmers Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-888-809-3434 Ext. 753
Pay online with credit card

Pekin Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-322-0160
Pay online with credit card or bank account

Progressive Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-776-4737
Pay online with credit card or bank account

Safeco Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-332-3226
Pay online with credit card or bank account

Selective Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-888-974-7400
Pay online with credit card or bank account

State Auto Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-444-9950 Ext. 5118
Pay online with credit card

Travelers Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-877-754-0471
Pay online with bank account

West Bend Mutual Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-800-573-1323
Pay online with credit card or debit card (if paying premium in full) or electronic check (may pay in installments or in full)

Zurich Insurance

Pay by phone: 1-866-350-7599
Pay online with credit card or bank account