Partners - Evansville & Newburgh, IN: Schultheis Insurance


Schultheis Insurance is proud to be associated with a broad array of insurance provider companies. Our partnerships with these companies allow us to obtain customized, cost-efficient insurance coverage for each of our individual or business clients.

To find out more about the companies with which you are insured, just click on the links below.

Accident Fund Insurance Company of America

Accident Fund provides workers’ compensation coverage and helps employers create a safe workplace.

AmComp Insurance

AmCOMP focuses exclusively on workers’ compensation insurance.

American Mining Insurance Company

American Mining provides lines of commercial insurance protection specialized for the mining industry.

American Physicians Insurance

American Physicians is the premier provider of medical liability insurance in the Midwest and New Mexico.

American Resources Insurance

Regional commercial lines, property and casualty insurance carrier.

Auto Owners Mutual Insurance

Auto-Owners Insurance offers life, home, car, or business insurance coverages.

Builders Insurance Group

Builders Insurance Group specializes in workers’ compensation and general liability for construction-centric accounts.

Cincinnati Insurance Companies

Cincinnati Insurance markets business, home, and auto insurance products.

Continental Western Insurance Group

Continental Western Group provides insurance products to a wide range of businesses and has developed specific areas of expertise, such as agriculture-based businesses, transportation, school districts and municipalities.

Eastern Alliance Insurance Group

Eastern Alliance Insurance Group issues workers’ compensation insurance policies for employers in Indiana and throughout the Midwest.

First Comp Insurance

First Comp provides workers’ compensation insurance for small and midsize businesses.

Foremost Insurance

Foremost Insurance is a specialty insurer offering a wide variety of home and other property insurance coverages.

Hastings Mutual Insurance

Hastings Mutual offers personal, business, and farm owners property and casualty insurance products.

Hartford Steam Boiler Insurance

The Hartford Steam Boiler Inspection and Insurance Company is a specialty provider of equipment breakdown insurance products for a variety of businesses.

Indiana Insurance

Indiana Insurance provides a broad range of insurance coverages for businesses.

Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance

Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance is a provider of auto, home, business, and farm insurance.

Illinois Casualty

Illinois Casualty Company specializes in liability protection for businesses in the food and beverage industry, including liquor liability insurance.

Jewelers Mutual Insurance

Jewelers Mutual Insurance specializes in insuring jewelry and jewelry businesses.

Kentucky Employers Mutual Insurance

Kentucky Employers Mutual Insurance is a leading provider of workers’ compensation insurance in Kentucky.

Magna Carta Insurance

Magna Carta Insurance is a group of companies offering a variety of commercial insurance coverages, including coverage for apartment and condo buildings and restaurants, as well as equipment breakdown insurance, workers’ comp insurance and other specialty lines.

Markel Insurance Company

Markel Insurance provides liability insurance for a variety of usual and unusual businesses and organizations, for example, youth sports programs, cheerleading gyms, B & B’s and inns, camps, fitness programs, museums, and historic homes.

Medical Protective Insurance

Medical Protective Insurance is a leading provider of medical liability insurance.

Midwest Insurance

Midwest Insurance Company provides workers’ compensation insurance coverages.

National Specialty Insurance

National Specialty Insurance (NSI) offers specialized programs, including property and casualty insurance, for risks that are normally not offered by standard-lines companies.

Pekin Insurance

Pekin Insurance offers a broad range of insurance coverages for individuals and businesses.

Philadelphia Insurance

Philadelphia Insurance offers commercial insurance products, specialty business insurance, and commercial auto insurance.

Progressive Insurance

Progressive Insurance offers auto insurance as well as coverage for boats, RVs, and motorcycles. In addition, they provide home owners, condo and renters insurance coverage, as well as coverage for commercial vehicles.

Safeco Insurance

Safeco offers insurance coverage for individuals.

Sagamore Insurance

Sagamore offers small fleet commercial truck insurance.

Selective Insurance

Selective offers coverage for a variety of businesses and organizations.

State Auto Mutual Insurance

State Auto insurance covers individuals’ homes, autos, boats, as well as farms and businesses.

Travelers Insurance

Travelers offers a full line of coverages for businesses of all sizes.


VSP offers individual Vision insurance.

West Bend Mutual Insurance

West Bend Mutual provides business insurance coverage including liability, specialized small business owners policies, and workers’ comp.

Westport Insurance

A Swiss Re company, Westport Insurance offers professional liability insurance coverage.

Zenith Insurance

Zenith Insurance provides workers’ comp insurance and workplace safety education for small businesses.

Zurich Insurance

Zurich North America offers customized insurance and risk management programs for commercial enterprises of all types and sizes.